Dycom Industries, Inc. (DY): A Bear Case Theory

We came crossed a bearish thesis connected Dycom Industries, Inc. connected Valueinvestorsclub.com by Coffee capital. In this article, we volition summarize the bulls’ thesis on DY. Dycom Industries, Inc.'s share was trading astatine $340.02 as of December 17th. DY’s trailing and forward P/E were 34.21 and 29.94  respectively according to Yahoo Finance.

ESB Professional/Shutterstock.com

Dycom Industries is simply a highly cyclical operation institution heavy reliant connected telecom wireline capex, presently trading astatine highest multiples that connote durable growth, contempt operating astatine the process extremity of a decade-long FTTH buildout cycle. Revenue maturation implicit the past 5 years has been driven by secular FTTH enlargement and insignificant M&A, but marketplace penetration has already reached 42% of full imaginable homes, and is expected to surpass 50% by aboriginal 2026. Once the FTTH capex rhythm peaks astir 2026–2027, wireline walk volition decelerate, and attraction revenues volition diminution as fiber’s lower upkeep costs trim the TAM for Dycom’s legacy copper, coaxial, and DSL work.

The company’s dense reliance connected a fewer large telecom clients compounds risk, with the AT&T–Lumen and Verizon–Frontier mergers concentrating implicit 66% of gross among lone 5 customers, introducing imaginable borderline unit and net volatility. Dycom’s reported $8 cardinal backlog is mostly backward-looking and misleading, overstating gross visibility, portion its purported recurring work and attraction gross is intimately tied to caller FTTH deployments and volition erode arsenic bequest wireline assets are decommissioned.

Competitive threats from FWA and LEO outer net further unit ARPUs and bounds cost-per-passing upside, portion national BEAD backing is improbable to meaningfully benefit Dycom, and immoderate realized benefits would accelerate marketplace saturation. Even with imaginable opportunities from AI datacenter fiber builds, Dycom is poorly positioned comparative to competitors with powerfulness and long-haul expertise.

Collectively, these factors suggest important downside, with Dycom’s fundamentals apt to deteriorate done declining FTTH growth, lawsuit concentration, and borderline compression. At existent valuations, the banal trades arsenic a durable infrastructure provider, but a normalized aggregate of 12x EV/EBIT implies a ~57% downside, reflecting the extremity of the FTTH rhythm and secular pressures, making Dycom a structurally overvalued institution with precocious hazard to equity investors.