A proposed law could force California health insurers to explain claim denials

When Colleen Henderson’s 3-year-old girl complained of symptom portion utilizing the bathroom, doctors brushed it disconnected arsenic a urinary tract corruption oregon constipation, communal maladies successful the potty-training years.

Henderson, however, suspected it could beryllium thing worse, and asked for an ultrasound. The doc and ultrasound technician told her that her security provider, UnitedHealthcare, would not screen it, but Henderson decided to bash it anyway, charging the $6,000 process to her recognition card. Then came the news: There was a grapefruit-sized tumor successful her toddler’s bladder.

That was successful 2008. The adjacent 5 years, Henderson said, became a protracted conflict with UnitedHealthcare implicit paying for the specialists who yet diagnosed and treated her daughter’s uncommon condition, inflammatory pseudotumor. She appealed denial of sum for infirmary stays, surgeries and medicine to the insurer and authorities regulators, to nary avail. The Sacramento-area household racked up much than $1 cardinal successful aesculapian debt, she said, due to the fact that UnitedHealthcare had decided that treatments recommended by doctors were unnecessary. The household declared bankruptcy.

“If I had not fought bony and nail each measurement of the way, my girl would beryllium dead,” said Henderson, whose girl yet recovered and is present a thriving 20-year-old inferior astatine Oregon State University. “You wage a batch of wealth to person wellness insurance, and you anticipation that your wellness security has your well-being astatine the forefront, but that’s not happening astatine all.”

While security denials are on the rise, surveys amusement fewer Americans appeal them. Various analyses person recovered that galore of those who escalate complaints to government regulators successfully get denials overturned (unlike the Hendersons). Consumer advocates and policymakers accidental that’s a wide motion security companies routinely contradict attraction they shouldn’t. Now a connection successful the California legislature seeks to penalize insurers who repeatedly marque the incorrect call.

While the measure, Senate Bill 363, would screen lone astir a 3rd of insured Californians whose wellness plans are regulated by the state, experts accidental it could beryllium 1 of the boldest attempts successful the federation to rein successful wellness insurer denials — earlier and aft attraction is given. And California could go 1 of lone a fistful of states that necessitate insurers to disclose denial rates and reasoning, information the manufacture often considers proprietary information.

The measurement besides seeks to unit insurers to beryllium much judicious with denials, by fining them up to $1 cardinal per lawsuit if much than fractional of appeals filed with regulators are overturned successful a year.

In 2023, state information show, astir 72% of appeals made to the Department of Managed Health Care, which regulates the immense bulk of wellness plans, resulted successful an insurer’s archetypal denial being reversed.

“When you person wellness insurance, you should person assurance that it’s going to screen your healthcare needs,” said Sen. Scott Wiener, the San Francisco Democrat who introduced the bill. “They tin conscionable delay, deny, obstruct, and, successful galore cases, debar having to screen medically indispensable care, and it’s unacceptable.”

A spokesperson for the California Assn. of Health Plans declined to comment, saying the radical was inactive reviewing the bill‘s language. Gov. Gavin Newsom’s spokesperson Elana Ross said his bureau mostly does not remark connected pending legislation.

Concerned astir spiraling user wellness costs, lawmakers successful states crossed the nation person progressively looked for ways to verify that insurers are paying claims fairly.

In 2024, 17 states enacted authorities dealing with anterior authorization of attraction by backstage insurers, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. For example, Connecticut, which has 1 of the astir robust denial complaint disclosure laws, publishes an annual report paper detailing the fig and percent of claims each insurer has denied, arsenic good arsenic the stock that ends up getting reversed. Oregon published akin accusation until recently, erstwhile authorities disclosure requirements lapsed.

In California, there’s nary mode to cognize however often insurers contradict care, which wellness experts accidental is particularly troubling arsenic intelligence wellness needs are reaching crisis levels among children and young adults. According to Keith Humphreys, a wellness argumentation prof astatine Stanford University, it’s easier to contradict intelligence wellness attraction due to the fact that a diagnosis of, say, slump tin beryllium much subjective than that of a breached limb oregon cancer.

“We deliberation it’s unacceptable that the authorities has perfectly nary thought however large of a occupation this is,” said Lishaun Francis, elder manager of behavioral wellness for the advocacy radical Children Now, a sponsor of the bill.

Under Wiener’s proposal, backstage insurers regulated by the state’s Department of Managed Health Care oregon Department of Insurance, oregon both, would beryllium required to taxable elaborate information astir denials and appeals. They would besides request to explicate those denials and study the outcomes of the appeals.

For appeals that marque it to the state’s autarkic aesculapian reappraisal process, oregon IMR, insurers whose denials are overturned much than fractional of the clip would look staggering penalties. The archetypal lawsuit that brings a institution supra the 50% threshold would trigger a good of $50,000, with a punishment ranging from $100,000 to $400,000 for a second. Each 1 aft that would outgo the institution $1 million.

If passed, the measurement would use to astir 12.8 cardinal Californians connected backstage insurance. It would not use to patients connected Medi-Cal, the state’s Medicaid program, oregon Medicare, and it would exclude self-insured plans offered by ample employers, which are regulated by the U.S. Department of Labor and screen astir 5.6 cardinal Californians.

The operation “deny and delay” continues to reverberate crossed the healthcare manufacture aft the killing of UnitedHealthcare Chief Executive Brian Thompson successful December. In a survey by the probe enactment NORC astatine the University of Chicago, conducted soon aft the attack, 7 successful 10 respondents said they believed denials for wellness sum and profits by wellness security companies bore a large woody oregon a mean magnitude of work for Thompson’s death.

Following Thompson’s death, UnitedHealthcare said successful statements that “highly inaccurate and grossly misleading information” had been circulated astir the mode the institution treats claims, and that insurers, which are highly regulated, “typically person low- to mid-single digit margins.”

Wiener called Thompson’s sidesplitting a “cold-blooded assassination,” and said his measurement had grown retired of a narrower proposal that failed past twelvemonth aimed astatine improving intelligence wellness sum for children and adults nether property 26. But helium acknowledged that the public’s absorption to the sidesplitting underscored the long-simmering choler galore Americans consciousness astir wellness insurers’ practices and the urgent request for reform.

Humphreys, the Stanford professor, said the U.S. wellness strategy creates beardown fiscal incentives for insurers to contradict care. And, helium added, authorities and national penalties are paltry capable to beryllium written disconnected arsenic a outgo of doing business.

“The much attraction they deny, the much wealth they make,” helium said.

Increasingly, ample employers are starting to see connection successful contracts with assertion administrators that would penalize security providers for approving excessively galore oregon excessively fewer claims, said Shawn Gremminger, president of the National Alliance of Healthcare Purchaser Coalitions.

Gremminger represents mostly ample employers that money their ain insurance, are federally regulated, and would beryllium excluded from Wiener’s bill. But adjacent for the alleged self-funded plans, it tin beryllium astir intolerable to find denial rates for the security companies hired simply to administer claims, helium said.

While the measure whitethorn beryllium excessively precocious for galore families, Sandra Maturino of Rialto said she hopes lawmakers tackle security denials truthful different Californians tin debar the saga she endured to get her niece treatment.

She adopted the girl, present 13, aft her sister died. Her niece had agelong struggled with self-harm and convulsive behavior, but erstwhile therapists recommended inpatient psychiatric care, her insurer, Anthem Blue Cross, would screen it for lone 30 days.

For much than a year, Maturino said, her niece cycled successful and retired of facilities and counseling due to the fact that her security wouldn’t screen a semipermanent stay. Doctors tested a laundry database of medicine drugs and doses. None of them worked.

Anthem declined to remark for this story.

Unlike truthful galore others successful akin situations, Maturino was yet capable to get extracurricular assistance to remedy the situation. She asked her adoption bureau for help, and it ended up covering the outgo of her niece’s enactment successful a residential programme successful Utah, wherever she was diagnosed with bipolar upset and has been undergoing attraction for a year.

Maturino said she didn’t person the vigor to entreaty to Anthem.

“I wasn’t going to hold astir for the security to termination her, oregon for her to wounded somebody,” Maturino said.

KFF Health News is simply a nationalist newsroom that produces in-depth journalism astir wellness issues and is 1 of the halfway operating programs astatine KFF — the autarkic root for wellness argumentation research, polling, and journalism.