Woman Refuses to Buy New Car for Accident-Prone Stepdaughter After Third Crash, Says She's 'Not a Good Driver'

• A pistillate seeks proposal from the Reddit assemblage aft refusing to assistance her accident-prone stepdaughter bargain a caller car

• Despite a caller clang not being her stepdaughter's fault, the pistillate is sticking to long-standing household rules connected car ownership

• The hubby wants to assistance with repayment terms, but the stepmom worries it'll acceptable a costly precedent

A pistillate is turning to Reddit for proposal aft she refused to bargain her stepdaughter a caller car pursuing aggregate accidents.

The poster begins by describing her stepdaughter arsenic “not a bully driver,” noting that this has been an ongoing contented since the young pistillate archetypal started driving arsenic a teenager.

“When she was archetypal learning to drive, she did precise accelerated hard breaks, and she repeatedly near her car’s lights connected oregon near her car unlocked,” the pistillate writes successful her post.

When the stepdaughter turned 16 and received her learner’s permit, the household established wide rules regarding car ownership. The pistillate explains that portion they were consenting to assistance acquisition her archetypal car, the stepdaughter was liable for each different expenses, including insurance, state and maintenance.

“If she wanted a car, she needed to beryllium the sole caretaker of it and it was connected her to guarantee she was taking bully attraction of it,” she states, noting that these rules applied arsenic to her brothers.

Unfortunately, accidents began occurring soon after. At property 17, conscionable 3 months into driving, the teen had her archetypal mishap portion driving connected ice. While not serious, it caused $1,000 successful damages.

Related: Mom Refuses to Pay Off Son's $15,000 Credit Card Debt, Says He Needs to Learn Financial Responsibility Instead

The stepmom noted that this incidental wasn’t wholly astonishing fixed the car’s age, revealing it had much than 160,000 miles connected it, and its transmission failed 2 months later.

Two years later, astatine property 19, different mishap occurred, but this clip it was connected a highway. A semi-truck attempted to merge adjacent to the teen's vehicle, prompting her to velocity up. Simultaneously, different car tried to merge arsenic well, resulting successful a collision that totaled her vehicle.

While injuries were minor, the fiscal consequences were significant. “Because of this accident, we made her get her ain security due to the fact that our outgo went up,” the poster reveals.

The astir caller mishap happened little than a period agone erstwhile the stepdaughter was driving connected the road adjacent an on-ramp. A pickup motortruck hydroplaned and mislaid power of a ladder successful its bed, starring to different collision that totaled her car.

This time, injuries were much terrible arsenic she near with whiplash, a enarthrosis wounded and facial damage. While constabulary indicated that this mishap wasn’t her fault, the household is inactive waiting for security to marque an authoritative determination.

Never miss a communicative — motion up for PEOPLE's escaped regular newsletter to enactment up-to-date connected the champion of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from personage quality to compelling quality involvement stories.

After returning location from the exigency country pursuing this latest incident, the stepdaughter asked her parents for assistance purchasing a caller car. But, the pistillate feels powerfully that this petition is unreasonable fixed their anterior statement and the young woman's past of accidents.

“She said that it’s not applicable for her to perpetually locomotion everyplace until she could spend a caller car,” the pistillate writes. However, she points retired that her stepdaughter lives successful an country with sidewalks and is wrong walking distances to cardinal locations including college, the market store and work.

While acknowledging it is challenging, the poster believes her stepdaughter tin negociate without contiguous assistance by walking oregon relying connected ridesharing apps until she saves capable wealth for different vehicle.

Though the pistillate is adamant connected not helping retired the stepdaughter this clip around, her hubby disagrees with this stance and has projected buying her a caller car with repayment presumption attached.

Related: Woman's Family Says She's 'Selfish' for Refusing to Let Parents Dip Into Her College Fund to Help Pay for Brother's Wedding

But, the pistillate is disquieted this volition acceptable an unsustainable precedent for their household finances. “To date, the lone clip we person ever helped bargain a car is erstwhile they each started driving…If we commencement doing this now, we volition locomotion down a precise costly walk,” she shares.

The concern has sparked mixed reactions from friends and household members. Some enactment the thought of helping retired fixed the circumstances surrounding the astir caller accident, portion others hold with the woman’s determination to clasp steadfast connected the archetypal rules.

Now, the pistillate is wondering if she’s successful the incorrect for lasting her ground.

"She seems similar she’s trying truly hard to get a bully commencement successful beingness & had immoderate atrocious luck that wasn’t her fault; wherefore not indebtedness her other for a down outgo connected a amended car?" asks 1 Reddit commenter.

"I don't deliberation it's an ahole determination to lend her the wealth and she tin wage y'all back, if you tin spend it," writes another. "Reading done her database of accidents they each look similar that, genuine accidents. Completely unrelated to her being a atrocious operator oregon leaving the lights connected successful her car ... Not adjacent Lewis Hamilton could debar idiosyncratic aquaplaning into him retired of nowhere."

Read the archetypal nonfiction connected People