Reddit’s Loudest Walmart Critics Have a Point About That 46x Multiple

The world's biggest retailer, Walmart (NYSE:WMT) has shed 4.1% implicit the past month, sitting astatine $123.49 arsenic of March 11, and retail investors connected Reddit are not staying quiet. Social sentiment has swung decisively bearish, with scores clustering betwixt 18 and 32 implicit the past week aft concisely touching 72 (bullish) astir the February net release. Walmart bushed Q4 estimates connected some net and revenue, but its banal inactive fell aft guidance disappointed.

Walmart posted Q4 adjusted EPS of $0.74, beating the $0.73 estimate, and gross of $190.7B, topping estimates by 3.6%. The concern is genuinely evolving: eCommerce present represents 23% of Walmart U.S. nett sales, the planetary advertizing concern deed astir $6.4B, and store-fulfilled expedited transportation grew much than 60%. CEO John Furner called the infinitesimal transformational: "The gait of alteration successful retail is accelerating. It's exciting. And our fiscal results amusement that we're not lone embracing this change, we're starring it."

But FY27 guidance called for nett income maturation of lone 3.5% to 4.5%, missing the ~5% Wall Street expected. That miss, combined with a trailing P/E of astir 46x, is what acceptable Reddit ablaze.

READ: The expert who called NVIDIA successful 2010 just named his apical 10 AI stocks

This infographic illustrates the ascendant bearish societal sentiment for Walmart (WMT), driven by valuation concerns, an net paradox wherever the banal fell contempt beating estimates, and missed income maturation guidance.

The astir viral thread, "Walmart's ($WMT) Valuation Still Doesn't Make Any Fucking Sense" connected r/wallstreetbets, drew 339 upvotes and 152 comments. The author's cardinal argument: "Walmart is Schrödinger's stock: someway some a enslaved proxy antiaircraft that deserves a dirt-cheap discount complaint and a hyper-growth monster that deserves a nosebleed multiple."