Palisades Fire deadlock fuels fear that ideology is creeping into jury box — and Mangione could be next

A deadlocked assemblage for the antheral accused of sparking the inferno that led to the Palisades Fire has fueled fearfulness that ideology is making its mode into the assemblage box, with 1 erstwhile authoritative acrophobic that it could interaction Luigi Mangione's trial.

A national justice connected Friday declared a mistrial for the antheral accused of deliberately causing the Palisades Fire, Jonathan Rinderknecht, aft jurors failed to scope a unanimous verdict. He was arrested successful October 2025 and charged with demolition of spot by means of fire, pleading not blameworthy aft helium was charged. Ten of the California jurors thought Rinderknecht was not guilty, portion 2 thought helium was.

A pistillate who identified herself arsenic juror fig 4 spoke to media outlets aft the mistrial was declared, saying determination was "no proof," adding that a retrial, which the authorities plans to do, would beryllium a "waste of our American dollars."

Former national authoritative Neama Rahmani told Fox News Digital this could beryllium a lawsuit of assemblage nullification, but gave different crushed wherefore members of the assemblage whitethorn person been hesitant to convict Rinderknecht.

FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X

Left: Luigi Mangione successful court. Right: Jonathan Rinderknecht poses for a booking picture. (Curtis Means for DailyMail/Pool and Department of Justice)

"This could beryllium a lawsuit of assemblage nullification, oregon it could beryllium a lawsuit wherever the jurors are blaming different people, oregon government, folks similar Karen Bass, the Los Angeles Fire Department," helium said. "In this peculiar case, it took 9 months for the Department of Justice to apprehension and complaint Jonathan Rinderknecht. And during that time, galore Angelenos who mislaid their homes, and determination are 12 radical who died, were pointing the digit astatine our section officials saying that they were not prepared for the precocious winds and yet the astir devastating occurrence successful California deed his."

While the Rinderknecht deadlock whitethorn person been driven by choler astatine section officials, Rahmani said the Mangione lawsuit presents a acold much nonstop nullification threat. Mangione is accused of assassinating UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson extracurricular a Manhattan edifice successful December 2024, a sidesplitting that drew wide nationalist sympathy toward the alleged gunman.

SIGN UP TO GET TRUE CRIME NEWSLETTER

Luigi Mangione appears astatine a pretrial proceeding successful Manhattan Criminal Court successful New York City connected June 17, 2026. (Pool via Barry Williams for New York Daily News)

With Rinderknecht's retrial acceptable for mid-October, astir the aforesaid clip Mangione's national proceedings could get underway, Rahmani warned prosecutors person small clip to hole for what helium called an unprecedented assemblage threat.

FEDERAL PROSECUTORS OFFICIALLY FILE INTENT TO SEEK DEATH PENALTY AGAINST LUIGI MANGIONE

"I bash deliberation the prosecution should beryllium acrophobic astir assemblage nullification successful the Luigi Mangione case. He's astir apt the astir fashionable accused murderer I've ever covered successful my 25 years of practice," Rahmani said. "And depending connected the surveys that you read, anyplace from 10 to 20% of radical judge that helium was justified successful what helium did."

SEND US A TIP HERE

He pointed retired that Mangione conscionable needs 1 idiosyncratic retired of a 12 idiosyncratic assemblage to beryllium sympathetic, and the numbers are successful his favor.

"The crushed wherefore that's an important fig is that you conscionable request 1 retired of 12 jurors if you're the defense. That's 8%. Mangione is simply a bully looking guy, helium is smart, helium comes from a affluent household and there's a enactment of radical extracurricular that courtroom each clip helium makes an appearance," Rahmani said. "Both the feds and the Manhattan DA's bureau has to beryllium precise cautious during assemblage enactment and marque definite that they region immoderate sympathetic Mangione jurors from the panel."

LISTEN TO THE NEW 'CRIME & JUSTICE WITH DONNA ROTUNNO' PODCAST

Even if the feds and Manhattan District Attorney's Office successfully region sympathetic Mangione jurors from the panel, a antithetic menace is inactive present, the erstwhile authoritative said: stealth jurors.

Stealth jurors — those who fell their existent biases to power a verdict — could airs a superior occupation for prosecutors successful either of Mangione's cases, Rahmani said.

LIKE WHAT YOU'RE READING? FIND MORE ON THE TRUE CRIME HUB

Luigi Mangione appears astatine a pretrial proceeding successful Manhattan Criminal Court successful New York City connected June 17, 2026. Mangione is accused of murdering UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson successful December 2024. (Pool via Barry Williams for New York Daily News)

"Stealth jurors are a immense occupation and it is not casual to place radical that privation to get connected the panel. Most radical don't privation to service arsenic jurors," helium said. "So erstwhile a juror really wants to beryllium connected the panels, it's 1 of the astir hard jobs of an lawyer to effort to ferret them out."

For Mangione, Rahmani said his lawsuit differs from Rinderknecht due to the fact that determination whitethorn beryllium immoderate jurors who "want to enactment our wellness security manufacture connected trial."

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

A sketch shows Jonathan Rinderknecht wrong national tribunal successful Orlando, Fla., connected Oct. 9, 2025. He faced charges for allegedly starting a New Year's Day occurrence that killed 12 radical successful Pacific Palisades, Calif. (Neftali Melendez/Unknown)

Ultimately, the erstwhile national authoritative says the occupation expands beyond immoderate azygous case.

"I bash judge assemblage nullification is much of an contented present than the past for 2 reasons. The state is much polarized and with societal media, you person everyone pursuing these trials successful a mode that you didn't person earlier erstwhile determination was section media sum only. Now radical each implicit the state are pursuing each azygous case, particularly these high-profile existent transgression cases," helium said.

Fox News Digital reached retired to Mangione's defence squad for comment.