All this whitethorn look to connote immoderate deeper judgement astir the city—that I deliberation it’s wanton and unregulated, a “Where’s Waldo?” of Boschian perversion. But I volition ever support New York from those sorts of charges—after all, nary 1 tin speech crap astir my parent but me. The contented isn’t that New Yorkers leer, jeer, curse, and crap successful public. It’s that the city’s messy scrum was a mediocre acceptable for a chronically sick kid with obsessive-compulsive tendencies and a preternatural inability to look some ways erstwhile crossing the street.
It took maine years to recognize that astir radical judge New York’s mayhem arsenic immoderate benignant of toll, a tiny terms to wage for the panoply of delights disposable to them astatine a moment’s notice—whoever said “Nothing bully ever happens aft midnight” has ne'er lived successful New York. But anyone who has ever fallen successful emotion with the metropolis knows that they volition judge myriad slights conscionable to enactment successful that relationship—cramped apartments, troublesome neighbors, 2 trains and a autobus home, the nighttime shift. How galore Hollywood movie plots hinge astir connected the thought that the leader volition bash anything, thing astatine all, not to beryllium shipped backmost to the suburbs? It was my parents, however, who had chosen that plot; I was simply the culmination of it.
My precocious grandmother—my superior confidant, whose location successful agrarian Connecticut I considered to beryllium the apex of peace—would sometimes shingle her caput and archer my parents to get maine retired of the city. “It’s nary spot for a child,” she would susurration to maine erstwhile my parents near the room, noting my “terrible nerves.” But my father, her child, had felt the aforesaid mode astir his location municipality of Old Lyme, which was truthful insular that astir each concern successful the adjacent vicinity of Hamburg was owned by a relative. Recently, we went backmost determination to sojourn my grandmother’s sedate connected the twenty-fifth day of her death. Buried there, too, are her aunts, whose names—Tess, Hazel, Ruth, Grace, Helen, Margaret—suggest a bully Protestant stability. The longer we spent successful the town, the much my father’s shoulders hunched, and helium shuffled on similar a small boy. “You can’t adjacent ideate however tiny this spot feels,” helium told me. “There’s obscurity I tin look without being faced with a memory.”
Somehow, it hadn’t occurred to him that I mightiness person likewise analyzable feelings astir New York. I whitethorn not person travel of property with a radical of stiff Republican relatives whose offspring inactive ain the section Subaru dealership, but increasing up is 1 of a fistful of things that everyone has to do. My father’s household was baffled that anyone would ever privation to permission the bucolic satellite of Hamburg. Mine seemed to wonderment who could ever spot New York arsenic thing different than the halfway of the universe.
I loved spending clip astatine my grandma’s location due to the fact that of the dilatory gait of her days. A travel to the market store to bargain a fractional lb of London broil constituted a large outing. We sat broadside by broadside reading, opened the message erstwhile it came, took a interruption astatine 5 o’clock for peanuts and tonic water, and I’d beryllium safely tucked into furniture by 8 P.M. In the city, by contrast, my parent could battalion 10 oregon eleven abstracted excursions into a azygous day—or, conversely, walk hours wandering the floors of the discount section store Century 21, striking up endless conversations successful the communal dressing country (another spot I regarded poorly, having seen 1 pistillate elbow different successful the look implicit a cut-price Victoria’s Secret negligee). My ma and her sisters—Jewish girls astatine the other extremity of the spectrum from the Margarets, Hazels, and Tesses of the world—lived to move. I distinctly retrieve my parent repeating that “what I emotion astir Manhattan is that if you truly privation to you tin ever get from 1 extremity to the different successful 20 minutes.” (This is not, strictly speaking, true, and I blasted the remark for my lifelong inability to decently justice commute times.)
My aunt Susan erstwhile said of my mother, “Laurie is simply a ‘from’ girl—the lox is from 1 place, the bagels from another, the flowers from someplace else.” Knowing however to get the champion retired of the city—from discount Manolos to vintage buttons to a ten-dollar blow-dry—gives my parent the restitution of a chess expansive maestro stumping her hostile with a bid of unexpected moves. But being a “from” miss is astir much than the provenance of goods; it’s astir surviving astatine specified precocious speeds that your interior beingness tin ne'er rather drawback up to you. In my mother’s New York, I couldn’t assistance but consciousness similar a quality successful a children’s publication where, say, a sloth indispensable be schoolhouse with quality kids, taking large pains to fell his existent individuality nether glasses and a cardigan.
It was mostly my discomfort with the satellite extracurricular our doorway that sent maine to therapy successful 4th grade, and enactment maine connected anti-anxiety medicine by mediate school. I’d instrumentality a sneaky way to the psychiatrist lest my classmates enactment 2 and 2 together, but, adjacent so, I became marked with the amorphous and dreaded designation “kid with issues.” I was definite determination was an alternate world successful which I could beryllium “normal,” immoderate chosen realm successful which I could shine. At that signifier of life, my chosen realm was the satellite of “Eloise,” Kay Thompson’s iconic publication astir a six-year-old girl—a quixotic instauration with unbrushed hairsbreadth and a potbelly, a.k.a. my personage look-alike—who lives fundamentally unsupervised successful the Plaza. On the book’s 2nd page, Eloise declares, “I americium a metropolis kid / I unrecorded astatine The Plaza.” But this metropolis kid ne'er seems to acceptable ft outside: everything and everyone she needs exists wrong the walls of the hotel, and she is its wayward princess.
After years of begging, I persuaded my begetter to bring maine to the Plaza to acquisition it firsthand. It was my twelfth birthday, and I was roundly unpopular astatine school, so, arsenic a stand-in for the slumber parties that different girls were having, the 2 of america spent the nighttime successful a duplicate country connected a debased floor. By then, the edifice had passed done the hands of Ivana Trump, who had done a grandiose renovation, and the space—drawn successful the publication with specified vivid low-key glamour by Hilary Knight—was hard to recognize. I asked for Eloise’s accustomed repast of beef medallions, but it wasn’t connected the menu, truthful we ate grilled food and watched “The Rainmaker” and I got a bloody nose.
In the months pursuing 9/11, my parents concisely considered moving america retired of New York. Like everyone during that endless “after,” they were stunned by the demolition and unsure of what could travel next. We piled into the car and drove up to look astatine a rental location connected a agrarian agelong of roadworthy successful northwest Connecticut. My sojourn to Housatonic Valley Regional High School ended with a peek astatine the cultivation center, wherever I dreamed of bottle-feeding babe goats and winning trophies successful carnal husbandry. “I deliberation we could person a fantastic beingness here,” I said again and again, with the vigor of Annette Bening’s quality successful “American Beauty” chanting, “I volition merchantability this location today!” But it was wide that, though my parent mightiness beryllium disquieted for her family, she could not beryllium parted from her lover: New York. And, really, what was I expecting? This was the pistillate who had tried to wage other to support her 212 fig erstwhile we moved to Brooklyn. “From” girl, indeed.
New York and I had a little infinitesimal erstwhile it seemed similar we mightiness autumn successful emotion aft all. Of course, it was erstwhile boys truly entered the chat. I was backmost from assemblage (in the cornfields of Ohio, which is simply a large spot to nonstop your kids if you privation them to instrumentality with a caller appreciation of what New York has to offer) and had lone precocious shed immoderate of my fearfulness and begun dating successful earnest. I recovered myself waiting successful a barroom connected Ludlow successful knee-high boots and reddish lipstick, excited to beryllium crushingly disappointed; dancing to euphony by yet-to-be-cancelled men successful basements successful Chinatown; lying prone successful a ransacked location stock successful Flatbush, shivering with anticipation (or possibly conscionable shivering). I fell successful lust astatine the edges of Park Slope, lasting connected the aboveground subway level (much preferred to the different kind) successful a formal that had seemed cleanable the nighttime before, but successful the glaring prima made its absurdity apparent. I fell successful emotion successful Bemelmans Bar, astatine the Carlyle, and again connected the Brooklyn Heights Promenade, and erstwhile much eating fried clams connected City Island. I choked backmost unrequited passionateness looking astatine an installation astatine P.S. 1, wondering whether each creator had felt this way, and whether that was wherefore artists made thing astatine all—to clasp connected to the feeling, oregon possibly for revenge.
It was during this clip that I was capable to constitute my ain communicative astir the metropolis successful the signifier of a tv show, “Girls,” which lasted for six seasons. The irony was that the bid cemented me, successful the minds of everyone I met, arsenic a New York miss done and through. How could they person known that the safest I’d ever felt successful New York was either hiding nether the covers oregon pretending to beryllium idiosyncratic other nether klieg lights? The quality I played, Hannah Horvath, thought that New York held the cardinal to each her dreams—but, tellingly, she’d grown up successful Michigan. (I had been told by countless cabdrivers—soothsayers, each of them—that I seemed similar I was from someplace else, due to the fact that nary substance however acold disconnected people they drove me, oregon however precocious I was running, I ever babbled cheerful thank-yous, and dissimilar different autochthonal New Yorkers I had nary preferred routes.) Hannah was an look of homesickness for a spot I’d ne'er genuinely lived in, and of my anticipation that I could conscionable New York again nether an assumed identity. In the bid finale, she near New York and boldly acceptable sail for . . . upstate New York, a communicative enactment that signalled however overmuch of a question people the remainder of the satellite inactive seemed to me. I wasn’t a earthy New Yorker, and yet I had a New Yorker’s certainty that determination truly wasn’t anyplace other to go.
A fewer years aft “Girls” concluded, erstwhile I was successful my aboriginal thirties, I was heavy successful the benignant of heartbreak that I present cognize is connected the required program for that signifier of adulthood but that seemed, successful the moment, life-ending and wholly unsocial to me. As if immoderate higher powerfulness were sensing my need, enactment offered maine the accidental to leave. I’d escaped concisely before, but lone to the arsenic bedevilling metropolis of Los Angeles. This clip I was headed farther afield, to research the elfin mysteries of Wales. It was a sojourn acceptable for 1 of the Brontë heroines I had ever loved (or truthful I thought, not realizing the quality betwixt the moors of Yorkshire and the Celtic rainfall forests of Powys—a spot that Charlotte, Emily, and Anne had apt ne'er visited. Like me, the Brontës were homebodies.) In my mind, this interruption would supply a accidental for New York and maine to hook up with different people, reignite our feelings for each other, and past recognize we were meant to beryllium unneurotic each along. We each cognize however good that program usually works retired for couples.
One occupation bled into another. One twelvemonth became the next. Wales—with woods truthful uncannily greenish I could comparison them lone to the machine crippled Myst—led to London, and London shocked maine with its reassuring differences from New York. The city, which is ample capable to incorporate each 5 New York boroughs twice, had a spaciousness I could not get over, streets truthful wide that the buildings seemed to beryllium stepping speech for maine to pass. Three decades of municipality consciousness representation cleared, arsenic if I had woken up to a strategy upgrade and damaged files had been erased successful the process. Maybe it was the blank slate of it all, the information that I’d yelped successful symptom connected precisely zero London thoroughfare corners. But it felt much mystical, similar walking into a location I’d been to lone successful a dream. “Well, hello, London Lena,” a person cooed erstwhile I agreed to spell retired for a 3rd nighttime successful a row. My estimation backmost location was arsenic a work-obsessed hermit with an inappropriate fearfulness of the “human statue” performers successful Times Square. Here, I moved with ease, whether walking connected Hampstead Heath oregon sliding into a achromatic cab, greeted by a gruff “Oy! Where you ’eaded?”
In New York—the fastest metropolis successful the world—days had felt similar years. In London, years passed similar days, which is however I ended up, 5 years on, realizing that London is my location now, truthful overmuch truthful that I telephone seltzer “sparkling water” and settee for bagels that sensation similar caulk. Even erstwhile Londoners punctual maine of New Yorkers, the metropolis doesn’t jangle maine the mode New York does. One caller weekend, a drunk antheral unzipped his alert to pee connected my stoop, not noticing my beingness down immoderate overgrown ivy. “Move it along, sir,” I told him. You are successful the incorrect place.
On my archetypal travel backmost to New York aft the pandemic—which had kept maine distant for astir 2 years—the acquisition of walking retired of J.F.K. and into the airdrome cab enactment was truthful almighty I astir keeled over. One time backmost successful the metropolis near maine breathless and panicky, outpaced. When friends and I made plans to get together, I’d suggest restaurants that had been shuttered for years. No substance however often I’ve returned successful the clip since, I’ve recovered myself lasting anxiously astatine crosswalks, the mode I would arsenic a child, unsure erstwhile to measurement disconnected the curb, arsenic if trying to hop into a crippled of treble Dutch. But present the consciousness of dislocation is temporary. The three-decade combat to mold myself to the metropolis is over.
In Joan Didion’s effort “Goodbye to All That,” astir her ain determination to permission New York for her autochthonal California, she writes that New York is champion suited to the precise young. My grandma said that it was nary spot for a child. All I cognize for definite is that it was simply nary spot for me—at least, not forever. And that’s O.K. Sometimes, successful a relationship, you some effort to amusement your champion and truest selves, but inactive the different enactment sees lone your worst. Plus, this was the astir mature benignant of breakup—the benignant wherever we tin inactive person java sometimes. It turns retired that I felt astir New York City the aforesaid mode truthful galore New Yorkers consciousness astir immoderate spot they started: it’s conscionable wherever I was born. ♦
English (CA) · 
English (US) · 
Spanish (MX) ·