Judge says Maryland man's erroneous deportation to El Salvador prison 'shocks the conscience'

A national justice is defending her determination to bid the Trump medication to facilitate the instrumentality of Kilmar Abrego Garcia from a notorious El Salvador situation by Monday and has denied the government's petition to enactment her bid portion it appeals her decision.

In a caller tribunal filing, U.S. District Judge Paula Xinis called the government's determination to nonstop the 29-year-old Abrego Garcia to El Salvador's CECOT situation a "grievous error."

A U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) authoritative admitted successful a sworn declaration connected March 31 that an "administrative error" led to Abrego Garcia, who is joined to a U.S. citizen, being sent to El Salvador contempt a 2019 tribunal bid barring the authorities from deporting him to his location country.

"As Defendants acknowledge, they had nary ineligible authorization to apprehension him, nary justification to detain him, and nary grounds to nonstop him to El Salvador – fto unsocial present him into 1 of the astir unsafe prisons successful the Western Hemisphere," Xinis wrote successful the tribunal document, filed Sunday.

MORE: DOJ places elder lawyer connected permission successful lawsuit of mistakenly deported man

In 2019, an migration justice issued a withholding of removal bid for Abrego Garcia, prohibiting the authorities from sending him backmost to his location state due to the fact that helium feared persecution determination from gangs.

Judge Xinis argued that Abrego Garcia's placement successful the El Salvadorian mega-jail contempt the "risk of harm shocks the conscience."

"Defendants person forcibly enactment him successful a installation that intentionally mixes rival pack members without immoderate respect for protecting the detainees from 'harm astatine the hands of the gangs,'" the justice wrote.

"Defendants person claimed – without immoderate grounds – that Abrego Garcia is simply a subordinate of MS-13 and past housed him among the main rival gang, Barrio 18. Not to notation that Barrio 18 is the precise pack whose years-long persecution of Abrego Garcia resulted successful his withholding from removal to El Salvador," Xinis further wrote.

Abrego Garcia's attorneys person maintained that helium is neither a subordinate of nor has immoderate affiliation with Tren de Aragua, MS-13, oregon immoderate different transgression oregon thoroughfare gang. They besides reason that the U.S. authorities "has ne'er produced an iota of grounds to enactment this unfounded accusation."

MORE: Judge orders authorities to instrumentality Maryland antheral deported successful 'error' to El Salvador

In Sunday's filing, Xinis wrote that the authorities has not produced immoderate grounds to suggest they cannot unafraid Abrego Garcia's instrumentality and said that the tribunal retains jurisdiction successful the lawsuit due to the fact that Abrego Garcia challenges his removal to El Salvador, "not the information of confinement."

"They bash so cling to the stunning proposition that they tin forcibly region immoderate idiosyncratic – migrant and U.S. national alike – to prisons extracurricular the United States, and past baldly asseverate they person nary mode to effectuate instrumentality due to the fact that they are nary longer the 'custodian,' and the Court frankincense lacks jurisdiction," Xinis wrote.

"As a applicable matter, the facts accidental otherwise," Xinis added.

Citing Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem's ain words from a video posted March 26 connected X that the CECOT situation is "one of the tools successful our toolkits that we volition use," Xinis said the grounds reflects that the defendants person "outsourced portion of the U.S. situation system."

"Just arsenic successful immoderate different declaration facility, Defendants tin and bash support the powerfulness to unafraid and transport their detainees, Abrego Garcia included," Xinis wrote.

Xinis besides included immoderate of the arguments made by Erez Reuveni, the U.S. Department of Justice lawyer who argued connected behalf of the authorities connected Friday successful a suit brought by Garcia's family. Reuveni was placed connected administrative permission by the DOJ implicit what the section alleged was a "failure to zealously advocate" for the government's interests during the hearing.

"As their counsel suggested astatine the hearing, this is not astir Defendants' inability to instrumentality Abrego Garcia, but their deficiency of desire," Xinis wrote.

During Friday's hearing, Xinis asked Reuveni, "Can we speech about, then, conscionable precise practically, wherefore can't the United States get Mr. Abrego Garcia back?"

"Your Honor, I volition say, for the Court's awareness, that erstwhile this lawsuit landed connected my desk, the archetypal happening I did was inquire my clients that precise question. I've not received, to date, an reply that I find satisfactory," Reuveni responded.

MORE: What we cognize astir the overseas assemblage students targeted for deportation

Xinis claimed successful Sunday's filing that, portion the ineligible ground for the Trump administration's determination to deport implicit 200 alleged pack members to El Salvador "remains disturbingly unclear," determination is nary ineligible grounds for Abrego Garcia to beryllium among them.

"Nor does immoderate grounds suggest that Abrego Garcia is being held successful CECOT astatine the behest of Salvadoran authorities to reply for crimes successful that country. Rather, his detention appears wholly lawless," Xinis wrote.

On Saturday, the Trump medication filed an exigency question to enactment Judge Xinis' order. The appellate tribunal has fixed Abrego Garcia's ineligible squad until 2 p.m. Sunday to respond.

In March, Abrego Garcia was stopped by ICE officers who "informed him that his migration presumption had changed," according to his attorneys. After being detained implicit alleged pack affiliations, helium was transferred to a detention halfway successful Texas. He was past sent to El Salvador connected March 15, according to a ailment his lawyers filed past period successful a U.S. District Court successful Maryland.

During a quality league connected Friday, Abrego Garcia's wife, Vasquez Sura, demanded that the Trump medication instrumentality her hubby to the United States.

"If I had each the wealth successful the world, I would walk it each conscionable to bargain 1 thing: a telephone telephone to perceive Kilmar's dependable again," Vasquez Sura said. "Kilmar, if you tin perceive me, I miss you truthful much, and I'm doing the champion to combat for you and our children."

Judge says Maryland man's erroneous deportation to El Salvador situation 'shocks the conscience' primitively appeared connected abcnews.go.com