I'm 58 With $1.5M Saved and a Small Mortgage — Should I Pay It Off Before Retirement?

Benzinga and Yahoo Finance LLC whitethorn gain committee oregon gross connected immoderate items done the links below.

Picture this: James is 58 years old. He's built up astir $1.5 cardinal successful status accounts and inactive has a humble owe connected his home.

He doesn’t emotion the thought of carrying indebtedness into retirement, and the thought keeps coming back: should helium conscionable instrumentality a ample withdrawal from his IRA oregon 401(k), wage disconnected the house, and beryllium done with it?

On the surface, the determination feels responsible. No mortgage. No monthly payment. One little work erstwhile enactment ends.

But this determination isn’t conscionable astir eliminating debt. It sits astatine the intersection of taxation math, marketplace risk, and psychology, and the incorrect determination tin softly outgo James six figures. The close reply depends little connected instinct and much connected timing.

Don’t Miss:

• This Jeff Bezos-backed startup volition let you to become a landlord successful conscionable 10 minutes, with minimum investments arsenic debased arsenic $100.

• Maximize redeeming for your status and chopped down connected taxes: Schedule your escaped telephone with a fiscal advisor to commencement your fiscal travel – nary cost, nary obligation. 

The astir evident solution (pulling $200,000 oregon $300,000 retired of status accounts to hitch retired the mortgage) is besides the astir expensive.

At 58, James is inactive nether 59½, which means astir IRA and 401(k) withdrawals trigger a 10% early-withdrawal penalty, connected apical of mean income taxes. That punishment unsocial takes a meaningful wound earlier taxes adjacent participate the picture.​

A $300,000 withdrawal is simply a utile example.

Between the 10% punishment and national income taxes astatine his apt 2026 taxation bracket (22–24%), it’s wholly imaginable for $100,000–$170,000 of that withdrawal to vanish to the IRS earlier a azygous dollar goes toward the mortgage.​

James liquidates a ample chunk of his status savings, but lone a fraction of it really pays down the house.

That’s conscionable the archetypal furniture of cost.

There’s a secondary interaction astir radical overlook: Large withdrawals inflate James’s taxable income, which tin impact aggregate parts of his fiscal life, adjacent years later.​

• Social Security taxation: If James plans to assertion benefits astatine 62 oregon later, the other income pushes him into the “tax torpedo” portion wherever 85% of his benefits tin go taxable. This creates an effectual marginal taxation complaint exceeding 20% connected the IRA withdrawal.​

• Medicare premiums: A $300,000 withdrawal could trigger income-related monthly accommodation amounts (IRMAA) surcharges, raising his Part B and Part D premiums by $80–$140+ per period for years.​

• Lost compounding: Once that wealth is gone, it’s nary longer compounding wrong tax-advantaged accounts. Over 15 years astatine 7% growth, $300,000 could go $850,000. That mislaid maturation compounds the existent outgo of the withdrawal.​