How much red meat is too much? Experts weigh in on food pyramid updates

The merchandise of an updated nutrient pyramid this week has sparked mixed reactions from doctors and dietitians.

One of the astir noteworthy shifts successful the 2025-2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans — which were announced by HHS officials during a Jan. 7 property league astatine the White House — is simply a greater accent connected "high-quality proteins," including reddish nutrient and eggs, arsenic good arsenic full-fat dairy.

The caller guidelines absorption connected "real, whole, nutrient-dense foods," and a melodramatic simplification successful highly processed foods, added sugars, refined carbohydrates and unhealthy fats.

HEALTH EXPERTS REACT AS ANDREW HUBERMAN BACKS TRUMP ADMIN’S NEW FOOD PYRAMID

"Protein and steadfast fats are indispensable and were wrongly discouraged successful anterior dietary guidelines," Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said during the property conference. "We are ending the warfare connected saturated fats."

Nick Norwitz, a Harvard- and Oxford-trained researcher known for his enactment successful metabolic health, shared his absorption to the caller guidelines.

The merchandise of an updated nutrient pyramid this week has sparked mixed reactions from doctors and dietitians. (realfood.gov)

Despite however the caller pyramid is presented, helium noted, the existent guidelines for saturated abdominous depletion haven't changed, arsenic they inactive state, "in general, saturated abdominous depletion should not transcend 10% of full regular calories."

The intake of unprocessed full foods affluent successful saturated fat, particularly dairy fat, tends to beryllium associated with improved wellness outcomes, according to Norwitz.

RED MEAT CAN HELP YOUR MOOD IF PART OF A HEALTHY, BALANCED DIET, STUDY SUGGESTS

"Full-fat dairy — particularly cheese, for illustration — tends to beryllium associated with little BMI, reduced rates of diabetes and adjacent reduced dementia risk," helium told Fox News Digital. "There are, of course, nuances — but ‘ending the war’ connected saturated abdominous seems reasonable."

Risks vary, experts say

Experts cautioned astir the imaginable wellness risks of exceeding the recommended intake of saturated fat, including higher rates of LDL "bad" cholesterol, which is known to summation the hazard of cardiovascular disease.

"The proposal to bounds saturated abdominous to 10% of full calories is based connected the probe showing that higher rates summation LDL cholesterin and associated risks for cardiovascular disease," Sherry Coleman-Collins, a nutrient allergy dietitian and adept from the Atlanta metropolitan area, told Fox News Digital. 

One of the astir noteworthy shifts successful the 2025-2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans is simply a greater accent connected "high-quality proteins," including reddish nutrient and eggs, arsenic good arsenic full-fat dairy. (iStock)

Nutrition should beryllium personalized and is babelike connected aggregate factors, she said, including age, gender, enactment level and familial hazard factors.

"The full saturated abdominous an idiosyncratic mightiness safely devour is influenced by their size and full calorie needs, arsenic good arsenic perchance familial differences," Coleman-Collins said.

Norwitz agreed, adding that "the circumstantial nutrient root and enactment with the unsocial big and their broader dietary discourse should instrumentality the spotlight."

Dr. Pooja Gidwani, a treble board-certified doc of interior medicine and obesity medicine successful Los Angeles, pointed retired that not everyone has the aforesaid "tolerance" for saturated fats.

"If expanding saturated abdominous leads to a meaningful emergence successful LDL cholesterin oregon ApoB (Apolipoprotein B, a macromolecule recovered connected the aboveground of definite cholesterol-carrying particles successful the blood), that intake level is excessive for that individual, careless of improvements successful value oregon glucose metrics," she said.

TRUMP ADMIN'S NEW NUTRITION GUIDELINES TARGET ULTRA-PROCESSED FOODS, EASE UP ON RED MEAT AND SATURATED FATS

"This personalized attack becomes progressively important successful midlife and beyond, erstwhile cardiovascular illness becomes the ascendant operator of morbidity and mortality and erstwhile tolerance for cumulative atherogenic (artery-clogging) vulnerability is lower."

For those who request to trim LDL cholesterin oregon person a higher cardiovascular risk, the American Heart Association recommends an adjacent little magnitude of saturated fats — little than 6% of full regular calories.

Experts cautioned astir the imaginable wellness risks of exceeding the recommended intake of saturated fat, including higher rates of LDL "bad" cholesterol. (iStock)

Gidwani besides cautioned that diets emphasizing saturated abdominous could assemblage retired fibre and unsaturated fats, "both of which play autarkic roles successful cholesterin clearance, insulin sensitivity, gut wellness and inflammation."

"Saturated fat-heavy patterns are besides calorie-dense, which tin softly undermine semipermanent value absorption if intake is not cautiously regulated," she added.

Not each saturated fats are equal, experts say

The effects of saturated abdominous beryllium connected what circumstantial foods are being consumed, according to experts.

"I would urge choosing minimally processed oregon unprocessed forms of foods," said Tanya Freirich, a registered dietitian nutritionist successful Charlotte, North Carolina. "For example, successful spot of a blistery canine — which has additives, nitrites, sodium and fillers — consuming a chickenhearted thigh would beryllium a overmuch amended choice."

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

Gidwani reiterated that the magnitude of processing plays a large role.

"Processed meats are consistently associated with worse cardiometabolic outcomes and correspond the clearest class to limit," she said. "The hazard present is not lone saturated fat, but besides sodium load, preservatives and the broader dietary signifier they thin to accompany."

"Full-fat dairy — particularly cheese, for illustration — tends to beryllium associated with little BMI, reduced rates of diabetes and adjacent reduced dementia risk," an adept told Fox News Digital. (iStock)

Unprocessed reddish meat, the doc said, tin acceptable into an wide steadfast fare successful smaller amounts, peculiarly erstwhile consumed alongside fiber-rich plants and minimally processed foods.

"However, from a longevity perspective, it should beryllium viewed arsenic optional alternatively than foundational, particularly for individuals with elevated cardiovascular risk," she added.

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR HEALTH NEWSLETTER

When it comes to dairy, Gidwani noted that fermented options are "metabolically much favorable" than food oregon cream.

"However, saturated abdominous from dairy is inactive not indispensable to prioritize for metabolic wellness oregon longevity," she said. "Excessive reliance connected dairy abdominous tin displace healthier abdominous sources without offering wide semipermanent benefit."

CLICK HERE FOR MORE HEALTH STORIES

Overall, the doc recommends unsaturated abdominous sources, including extra-virgin olive oil, nuts, seeds, avocado and omega-3-rich fish, arsenic superior dietary fats.

"These consistently enactment lipid profiles, insulin sensitivity and vascular health," Gidwani said. "Saturated abdominous tin beryllium wrong a balanced diet, but it should stay secondary alternatively than emphasized."

Why the large representation matters

Saturated abdominous is conscionable 1 portion of a overmuch wider nutrition puzzle, the experts agreed.

"Our bosom wellness is not determined by 1 benignant of abdominous oregon 1 benignant of cholesterol, but the sum of galore parts: our full diet, our workout habits, our accent and truthful overmuch more," Freirich said.

Unprocessed reddish nutrient tin acceptable into an wide steadfast fare successful smaller amounts, peculiarly erstwhile consumed alongside fiber-rich plants and minimally processed foods, 1 adept said. (iStock)

She recommends consulting a registered dietitian for guidance connected unsocial dietary needs based connected age, gender, enactment level and aesculapian history.

TEST YOURSELF WITH OUR LATEST LIFESTYLE QUIZ

New Jersey-based dietitian Erin Palinski-Wade, writer of "2-Day Diabetes Diet," added that the connection should beryllium to absorption much connected wide patterns — "plenty of fiber-rich plants, thin macromolecule astatine each repast (including those that besides incorporate fiber, specified arsenic nuts and seeds) and a simplification successful wide intake of added sugars."

"That alteration volition thrust existent wellness improvements," she said.