Even if Trump secures Ukraine-Russia peace deal, can Putin be trusted?

Ukraine connected Tuesday agreed to a preliminary connection enactment guardant by the Trump medication that called for a 30-day ceasefire contingent connected Russia's acceptance of the presumption successful a large measurement toward ending the brutal war.

But adjacent if the Trump medication is capable to get Moscow to the negotiating array and extremity the three-year warfare nether a caller treaty, which respective information experts accidental Russian President Vladimir Putin is nether nary existent unit to do, tin the Kremlin main beryllium trusted?

Russia nether Putin has repeatedly violated ceremonial planetary agreements intended to support Ukraine’s sovereignty, chiefly from its erstwhile Soviet overlord.

From left, U.S. National Security Advisor Mike Waltz, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, Saudi Arabian Foreign Minister Prince Faisal bin Farhan, Saudi National Security Advisor Mosaad bin Mohammed al-Aiban, Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha and Ukrainian Head of Presidential Office Andriy Yermak clasp a gathering successful Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, Tuesday, March 11, 2025.  (Saul Loeb/Pool Photo via AP)

UKRAINE ACCEPTS DEAL, SAYS RUBIO: 'WE'LL TAKE THIS TO THE RUSSIANS'

These agreements see the 1994 Budapest Memorandum, successful which Ukraine agreed to relinquish its atomic arsenal successful speech for assurances implicit its territorial integrity aft its 1991 withdrawal from the Soviet Union, arsenic good arsenic the 1997 Treaty connected Friendship, Cooperation, and Partnership by which Moscow and Kyiv agreed to respect 1 another’s existing borders. Both deals were archetypal violated successful 2014 erstwhile Putin seized Crimea and backed Russian separatist forces successful the Donbas region. 

The 2014-2015 Minsk Agreements, though criticized arsenic "weak," attempted to extremity Russia’s aggression successful eastbound Ukraine, an statement that was ne'er afloat achieved and was again violated by Putin's 2022 invasion. 

Some satellite leaders and information officials, including Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, person cautioned that a bid woody betwixt Russia and Ukraine is improbable to beryllium achieved successful the adjacent word and against Putin’s reliability successful adhering to immoderate planetary statement without superior information commitments from the West.

"The occupation present is that the Russians lone recognize win-lose outcomes, which means that to forestall them from ever attacking Ukraine again, they indispensable spot themselves to beryllium the losers successful the warfare conscionable arsenic they did astatine the extremity of the Cold War," Michael Ryan, erstwhile lawman adjunct caput of Defense for European and NATO Policy and erstwhile acting adjunct caput of Defense for International Security Affairs, told Fox News Digital.

Ukrainian soldiers occurrence a cannon adjacent Bakhmut, an eastbound metropolis wherever fierce battles against Russian forces person been taking spot successful the Donetsk portion of Ukraine, May 15, 2023. (AP Photo/Libkos)

Security officials interviewed by Fox News Digital argued that securing Ukraine’s aboriginal is not astir "trusting" Putin. It’s astir really putting Russia successful a presumption wherever immoderate aboriginal violations would hinder Moscow much than it could beryllium enticed by unchecked opportunity.

TRUMP THREATENS SANCTIONS ON RUSSIA, DEMANDS PEACE AFTER MAJOR HITS IN UKRAINE

"Even if a woody is concluded, Russia volition proceed clandestine operations crossed the satellite to grow its footprint successful presumption of geopolitical influence," Rebekah Koffler, a erstwhile DIA quality officer, told Fox News Digital, noting the erstwhile KGB operative tin beryllium counted connected to "continue predetermination interference campaigns, cyber warfare, espionage and destabilization operations crossed the globe.

"There’s nary specified happening arsenic bid successful Russia’s strategical subject thinking. You are successful a changeless confrontation."

Ryan argued a Trump-brokered bid woody needs to bespeak connected the lessons learned from antecedently failed agreements, similar the post-WWI Treaty of Versailles, which arguably led to the emergence of Adolf Hitler and Nazi Germany.

"How to lick this conundrum? Just arsenic we did aft World War II … reconstruction of Ukraine indispensable see economical reconciliation with Russia," Ryan said. "The Russians saw however we rebuilt the losing broadside successful World War II Germany and Japan. They expected america to bash the aforesaid for Russia aft the Cold War, but we did not.  

"We can't marque that aforesaid mistake if we privation lasting bid for Ukraine and if we privation to divided Russia from China," helium added, noting different adversaries are watching however the West handles this geopolitical hurdle.

Ukrainian soldiers of the Aidar battalion grooming astatine an undetermined determination successful Donetsk oblast, 4 April 2023. (Diego Herrera Carcedo/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)

There are galore obstacles erstwhile it comes to the Trump administration’s effort to negociate with Putin, including arguments implicit occupied territory, planetary designation of occupied lands, planetary assistance and enactment for Ukraine, planetary confiscation of frozen Russian assets, Zelenskyy’s lasting astatine home, the instrumentality of prisoners of warfare and the instrumentality of abducted Ukrainian children, according to Peter Rough, elder chap and manager of the Center connected Europe and Eurasia at the Hudson Institute.

"Putin has officially annexed 4 Ukrainian oblasts arsenic good arsenic Crimea. But Moscow has yet to conquer immoderate of the 4 entirely," Rough told Fox News Digital portion traveling to Ukraine. "I can’t ideate that Ukraine volition retreat from the areas they control, having fought bony and nail to support those regions. 

"I besides uncertainty that the West volition connection de jure designation to the areas Moscow controls," helium added. "So, Putin would person to swallow each of that successful a bid deal."

Each contented unsocial is simply a monolithic undertaking to negotiate, and while Ukraine this week whitethorn beryllium outlining concessions it could marque to unafraid a woody coordinated by the U.S., Putin is improbable to bash the same, according to Koffler, who briefed NATO years up of the 2022 penetration connected Putin’s plans.

RUBIO SAYS MINERAL DEAL ‘NOT MAIN TOPIC ON AGENDA’ IN UKRAINE MEETING

"Putin is improbable to marque immoderate concessions arsenic helium believes helium is successful a beardown position," Koffler told Fox News Digital. "The disparity successful combat imaginable dramatically favors Russia implicit Ukraine, which is out-manned and outgunned due to the fact that Putin transitioned the Russian subject and system connected a wartime footing 7 years anterior to the penetration of Ukraine."

Russian President Vladimir Putin chairs a gathering connected the draught of a 2024 national fund and the readying play of 2025 and 2026, via video nexus astatine the Kremlin successful Moscow, Russia, Sept. 18, 2023 (Sputnik/Mikhail Metzel/Pool)

"Putin believes helium has prepared Russia to combat till the past Ukrainian and till the past rocket successful NATO’s arsenal," she added, echoing a January informing issued by NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte, who said Russia’s defence manufacture output implicit a three-month play equates to what each of NATO produces an full year.

"Putin is highly improbable to hold to a ceasefire due to the fact that helium doesn’t privation to springiness a strategical intermission to Ukraine, the U.S., and NATO to re-arm," Koffler said. "He doesn’t spot Washington. He doesn’t spot President Trump immoderate much than we spot Putin. 

"He trusts Trump adjacent little than Biden due to the fact that helium could work Biden and foretell his behavior. He cannot work Trump due to the fact that Trump is unpredictable."

The experts argued determination are excessively galore variables that could play retired during negotiations that volition find whether Putin tin beryllium adequately held accountable oregon "trusted" regarding aboriginal agreements.

Ukrainian soldiers enactment with "pion" artillery successful the bluish absorption of the Donbass beforehand enactment arsenic the Russia-Ukraine warfare continues successful Donetsk, Ukraine, Jan. 7, 2023.  (Diego Herrera Carcedo/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP

Ultimately, Koffler said, Putin volition not permission eastbound Ukraine.

"Ukraine has ever been a reddish enactment for Putin, successful presumption of who has geopolitical power of it, Russia oregon the West. And helium volition proceed to enforce this reddish line," she said. "The lone mode to guarantee that Putin doesn’t invade different state is to marque NATO beardown again, beef up unit posture, summation defence spending, unafraid its command-and-control networks and make existent deterrence and counter-strategy that addresses each prong of Putin’s strategy."