Contributor: Mahmoud Khalil isn't a citizen. His deportation wouldn't be unlawful

The banal marketplace of precocious has been connected a veritable roller coaster, the alleged Department of Government Efficiency continues to ruffle feathers, Iran marches ever person to a atomic limb and Russia and Ukraine are getting tantalizingly adjacent to a cease-fire. But the nationalist governmental speech this week has curiously tended to absorption not connected immoderate of that, but alternatively connected protests implicit the uncertain destiny of a lone noncitizen and erstwhile Columbia University postgraduate student, Mahmoud Khalil.

Talk astir a misplacement of priorities. Most American media consumers attraction a large woody astir their pocketbooks and status accounts. They astir apt besides attraction astir stableness connected the satellite signifier — a subdued China, a comparatively calm Middle East and a long-overdue bid woody to extremity the bloodshed successful Eastern Europe.

By contrast, present is 1 happening media consumers astir apt don't attraction a batch about: Whether a Syrian nationalist and Algerian national who was the look of past year’s pro-Hamas Columbia University field riots gets deported. Is it immoderate wonderment that lone 31% of Americans told Gallup successful the autumn that they person a “great deal” oregon “fair amount” of assurance successful the media?

Read more: ICE arrests Palestinian activistic who helped pb Columbia University protests, his lawyer says

By immoderate metric, Khalil is simply a wildly unsympathetic figure. The New York Times described him arsenic the “public look of protestation against Israel” astatine Columbia. He acted arsenic the pb negotiator for a pro-Hamas pupil radical called Columbia University Apartheid Divest, which has referred to Hamas’ Oct. 7, 2023, slaughter of Israelis arsenic a “moral, military, and governmental victory” and asserted that it is warring for thing little than “the full eradication of Western civilization.”

Even much relevant, Khalil is not a U.S. citizen. He is simply a greenish paper holder, a “legal alien.” And helium tin stay connected our ungraded lone erstwhile the sovereign — successful the U.S., that’s “We the People” — consents to it. When we region our consent, that idiosyncratic tin beryllium deported.

The powerfulness to exclude is simply a defining diagnostic of what it means to beryllium a sovereign. Emer de Vattel’s highly influential 1758 treatise, “The Law of Nations,” described this powerfulness arsenic plenary: “The sovereign whitethorn forbid the entranceway of his territory either to foreigners successful general, oregon successful peculiar cases, oregon to definite persons, oregon for definite peculiar purposes, according arsenic helium whitethorn deliberation it advantageous to the state.” And arsenic the precocious Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia noted successful a citation successful a 2001 dissent, “Due process does not put immoderate alien with a close to participate the United States, nor confer connected those admitted the close to stay against the nationalist will.”

Read more: Contributor: Mahmoud Khalil's pro-Palestinian comments are protected speech, not grounds for deportation

It's rather simple, really: If idiosyncratic successful the U.S. connected a tourer visa oregon successful possession of a greenish paper violates the presumption of his admission, helium tin beryllium removed. That brings america backmost to Khalil — a overseas nationalist who allegedly violated the presumption of his sojourn by supporting astatine slightest 1 U.S. State Department-designated overseas violent organization, and by making communal origin with an enactment clamoring much mostly for the extremity of Western civilization. The time the United States loses the quality to deport noncitizens who espouse specified toxic beliefs is the time the United States ceases to beryllium a sovereign nation-state.

The Khalil saga is wherever we spot the intersection of the 3 toxic anti-Western ideologies. First, determination is the “woke” angle: Khalil represented CUAD, which espouses a neo-Marxist oppressor/oppressed dichotomy, and its presumption of Israel arsenic an “oppressor” underlies Khalil's repugnant activism. Second, determination is the Islamist angle: CUAD supports Sunni Islamist outfits specified arsenic Hamas. Third, determination is the planetary neoliberal angle: Those protesting Khalil’s detention spot small favoritism betwixt national and noncitizen — arsenic successful John Lennon’s dystopian opus “Imagine,” they envision a borderless world.

Khalil's apprehension and detention are frankincense lone successful portion astir Khalil. On Monday, the authoritative X relationship for the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee Democrats posted, alongside a corresponding photo, “Free Mahmoud Khalil.” But if those Senate Democrats and Khalil’s myriad different apologists are being honest, they question not simply to “free” Khalil from President Trump’s Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency. Rather, they question to escaped him — and each of america — from the shackles of Western civilization itself.

Josh Hammer's latest publication is "Israel and Civilization: The Fate of the Jewish Nation and the Destiny of the West." This nonfiction was produced successful collaboration with Creators Syndicate. @josh_hammer

If it’s successful the quality close now, the L.A. Times’ Opinion conception covers it. Sign up for our play sentiment newsletter.

This communicative primitively appeared successful Los Angeles Times.