The frescoes were excessively large successful color, critics said. Too modern. Too bladed and flat. The frescoes, the nine members complained, were “out of harmony” and ruining their enjoyment of their plot — and so, they decreed, the frescoes had to go.
It was 1933 astatine the Ebell of Los Angeles, a salient women’s nine founded successful 1894 that had for six years occupied a majestic caller gathering disconnected Wilshire Boulevard, built successful the Italian Renaissance benignant by famed designer Sumner P. Hunt. The club’s then-president, Anna May Dunlap, commissioned muralist and creator Maxine Albro to make frescoes for the northbound loggia of the Ebell’s plot — for which Albro toiled distant during the vigor of July and August that year.
Called “The Four Sibyls,” the frescoes picture the pistillate seers of past Greek and Roman mythology, including the Roman, Cumaean, Erythraean and Delphic sibyls. Albro had studied nether a pupil of Diego Rivera’s and would spell connected to go 1 of the country’s foremost pistillate muralists, moving with the Works Progress Administration connected projects including murals astatine San Francisco’s Coit Tower.
Albro’s Ebell frescoes were so agleam and modern — having been created successful the benignant precocious popularized by Rivera — and, similar galore large works of creation passim the ages, her creations sparked a pitched battle.

Conservator Kiernan Graves, left, Scholar-in-Residence Meredith Drake Reitan and Ebell Executive Director Stacy Brightman astatine the L.A. nine earlier this month.
(Carlin Stiehl / For The Times)

Frescos by Maxine Albro, painted successful 1933 successful the northbound loggia of the Ebell of Los Angeles.
(The Ebell of Los Angeles)
In what would spell down successful past arsenic the “Sibyl War,” Ebell members argued for 2 years astir the appropriateness of the frescoes, touching connected still-universal themes including who creation is for, wherefore creation matters, what art’s spot is successful society, and however advancement tin beryllium made if risks are ne'er taken.
“It is an astonishing happening that we tin go truthful funny successful creation treatment that our ‘sibyl war’ has widened creation appreciation,” Dunlap wrote successful 1934 earlier stepping down arsenic president due to the fact that of the controversy. “No longer are we confined to ‘kitchen, children and church,’ and we indispensable spot to it that these avenues are kept everlastingly unfastened for American women.”
The Sibyl War ended successful March 1945, with a ballot of 385 to 223 successful favour of the frescoes’ removal. The Times’ then-art critic, Arthur Millier, was a staunch advocator for the murals and wrote astir them galore times, including a peculiarly poignant plea for them to beryllium spared a week earlier they were slated for destruction.
“There is successful Los Angeles, successful a semi-public place, a enactment of creation which gives to a immense grey partition a freshness similar the enactment of spring, a lightsome quality similar the dawn of the Renaissance successful Tuscany,” Millier wrote. “This enactment of art, successful fact, is 1 of the signs of our ain California Renaissance — a happening of sure-footed youthfulness, and of agleam blessed color.”
“Every large enactment of creation was erstwhile caller and strange,” Millier noted. “Time unsocial — plentifulness of clip — tin marque its connection wide to all.”

Ebell’s student successful residence, Meredith Drake Reitan, holds images of the archetypal frescoes that person been rediscovered the Ebell.
(Carlin Stiehl / For The Times)
What happened to the frescoes remained a enigma for 90 years, said Meredith Drake Reitan, the Ebell’s archetypal student successful residence, who came crossed the past of the mislaid murals aft gaining entree to the Ebell’s immense archives. No grounds could beryllium recovered documenting the method utilized to region them, but humanities letters and quality clippings referred to techniques that would person resulted successful destruction, including dousing them with lye, chipping them disconnected the partition and sandblasting them.
Ebell Executive Director Stacy Brightman, aft proceeding chatter astir the mislaid Albros upon taking her post, decided to find out. Brightman hired Kiernan Graves, a wall-painting conservator who specializes successful murals and frescoes, to spot what she could find beneath what turned retired to beryllium much than 9 layers of paint. Graves began the enactment of revealing a 6-inch model of partition into creation history.
That was successful January, conscionable a fewer days aft fires devastated ample swaths of Pacific Palisades and Altadena. Graves remembered driving done the smoky haze to the beauteous Ebell garden.
“It was a truly grim time,” Graves says. “So to spot the colour appear, it was conscionable specified a agleam airy successful that infinitesimal — to consciousness similar thing is surviving alternatively than destroyed.”

A quadrate of an uncovered fresco uncovered by conservator Kiernan Graves astatine the Ebell. More than 9 layers of overgarment were removed utilizing antithetic chemicals to scope the archetypal art.
(Carlin Stiehl / For The Times)
Later that night, Brightman called Graves to cheque in, breathless with anticipation.
“Oh, girl, you got frescoes,” Graves told her.
The women laughter arsenic they archer the story. They beryllium astatine a polished woody array successful the Ebell’s lovingly preserved wood-paneled library. Visiting schoolchildren tin beryllium heard laughing during a presumption successful a adjacent auditorium wherever Amelia Earhart gave her past nationalist quality earlier disappearing implicit the Pacific Ocean. The ornate, stately gathering echoes with women’s history, adjacent arsenic its existent leaders infuse it with aboriginal purpose.
The recently discovered “lost” Albros are origin for large solemnisation astatine the center. The women who wanted to prevention the Albros, it turns out, not lone had photographed the frescoes for posterity earlier they were covered but besides had managed to guarantee they were simply painted over, knowing afloat good that their clip would travel astir to beryllium revealed again.
When looking done the archives, Reitan recovered grounds of the women’s resolve. “They accidental things like, ‘We whitethorn not recognize what we’re doing now, but women successful the aboriginal volition understand.’ They’re perfectly assured of that,” she says. “And truthful the thought that they really are here, and they lasted into the future, and that we present person the capableness to truly uncover them successful the due way, it’s conscionable perfectly incredible.”

Frescos by Maxine Albro, painted successful 1933 successful the northbound loggia of the Ebell of Los Angeles.
(The Ebell of Los Angeles)
Because the frescoes were covered up truthful quickly, they ne'er got the accidental to cure arsenic frescoes usually do, Graves says. This rendered them successful pristine information but besides made them rather fragile, which is wherefore aft uncovering respective 6-inch spots and confirming that the frescoes were intact, Graves instantly covered up the creation again.
In yet different twist for the prized works, it is unclear erstwhile they tin — and if they should — beryllium afloat uncovered and restored, Brightman says. The nonprofit Ebell, which is connected the National Register of Historic Places, indispensable acquisition a city-mandated seismic retrofit. The incredibly costly process volition apt past galore years and impact acold excessively overmuch particulate and operation chaos for the frescoes’ safety.
“This field is simply a jewel for Los Angeles. We person to prevention it and marque it sing for the adjacent century,” Brightman says, adding that the timing is good. “Ninety years of a enigma has been solved. The sibyls tin support sleeping safely, and we tin person a truly thoughtful speech astir what that means, and what the Ebell needs to look like, and be, arsenic we travel retired the different side.”